I know a lot of people nowadays talk about nuclear as this abundant energy source which is much cleaner than fossil fuels but this is exactly what was being said around the 70s, then we had two huge nuclear disasters. There’s two generations here that have starkly different views of nuclear energy.
Which is why you design it so human error cannot cause a nuclear incident. Which is what we’ve done with modern reactors. Many newer designs are objectively impossible to melt down, not just from the change in physics, but the safety features which cannot reasonably disabled and the oversight for regular inspections.
Well, everything breaks down after a while. Can’t make an everlasting reactor.
So you can’t completely release it from human error.
Of course, nuclear is definitely better than coal. But it takes so long to build, we’re better off focusing on renewables now. In 30 years we’d have switched almost completely to solar anyway.
Yes, but those new designs are more expensive, and since each reactor costs a loooot of money, governments take shortcuts, save money and then accidents happen.
They’re actually not that expensive, overall. The problem is inefficient bureaucracy around it. As a fun fact you can cut the cost in half by repurposing old coal, oil, and natural gas power plants.
No, we need that money to build out wind and solar now (there’s a climate collapse happening todey), we can’t wait 20+ years for a nuclear reactor to go online.
Fun fact, you still need base load reactors, and fun fact, it takes 5 years to build a nuclear power plant, to be specific, 68 months. From bare ground to fully online and synced with a grid.
But beyond that, solar is nice and can be useful, wind has some uses in some locations, but you have to be okay with being dependent on China since practically zero other countries make solar panels. There are a few, but 80% of all solar panels sold globally are made in China, and if we include local manufacturing, over 99% of all solar panels made are made in China.
I mean I’m okay with that, but EU people specifically get super weirded out by that. Most developed countries have all things necessary for a nuclear power grid and can ensure they can always repair, fuel, and maintain their power plants.
Fun fact, the very concept of base load has been obsolete for a decade. There are times on modern grids where the net power demand goes to zero due to all the solar deployed on rooftops and such. Base load of many grids is zero at this point.
So since we’re people and not angels, maybe we should stick with solar, wind, and batteries. There’s just less of a chance of us colossally breaking something with these.
Which is why you design it so human error cannot cause a nuclear incident.
BWAHAHAHA
Human error is always present. You can’t engineer around it. You can have the best, most safest design possible on paper, but it won’t do any good at all if it isn’t built and maintained the way you designed it.
If anti-nuclear people knew anything about nuclear power, they wouldn’t be anti-nuclear. The Chernobyl powerplant was an RMBK reactor, completely different in structure than other nuclear powerplants. The fossil fuel industry loves misguided opposition against nuclear energy. Read about the RMBK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RBMK
You support nuclear for psychological reasons, not for technological reasons. It gives you a sense of superiority over your fellow human beings. The real reason nuclear is a dead technology is that it’s simply not cost competitive with renewables and batteries, but you’re here pretending that it’s a bunch of scared superstitious ignorant environmentalists that are dragging it down. THOSE common fools just don’t know the science. THOSE morons just aren’t rational actors like you are. THEY are just to lazy to read about nuclear plant designs.
You’re engaged in a comforting form of self-delusion. The actual barriers to nuclear have nothing to do with people just being irrationally afraid of fission. But you ignore this because it gives you a sense of intellectual superiority.
You support nuclear for psychological rather than technological reasons. Fission is just your sports team.
Different but wrong. I am always interested to know what people’s guesses are for the total number of deaths caused by Chernobyl, because it’s remarkably low in my opinion. It’s by far the safest form of energy generation. Yes, even safer than wind power… why? Simply because wind is a very energy un-dense source of energy so you need to do a lot of construction to obtain it, and construction is a somewhat dangerous job - there’ll be some small number of people who fall off wind turbines (or off rooves while installing solar panels, or whatever) and the huge number of turbines works out as swamping the small number of nuclear plants and tiny number of deadly nuclear disasters.
Different but wrong. I am always interested to know what people’s guesses are for the total number of deaths caused by Chernobyl, because it’s remarkably low in my opinion.
There were roughly 350,000 innocent human beings who had to abandon their homes due to Chernobyl. The death total was only so low because hundreds of thousands of people had to literally flee for their lives.
We’ve already accepted the downsides: we’re all held at gunpoint by thousands of nuclear missiles on a daily basis for the past 5 decades and yet there seems to be more people worried about nuclear power than that. We could just as well take advantage of the upside as well.
I know a lot of people nowadays talk about nuclear as this abundant energy source which is much cleaner than fossil fuels but this is exactly what was being said around the 70s, then we had two huge nuclear disasters. There’s two generations here that have starkly different views of nuclear energy.
The two huge nuclear disasters in question: Unreasonable demands of management and a lack of safety protocol.
And building one on a fault line by the tsunami-prone sea
Fine. I’ll support building a nuclear plant if you can promise to build it without hiring any managers, executives, or accountants.
Human error is inevitable.
Which is why you design it so human error cannot cause a nuclear incident. Which is what we’ve done with modern reactors. Many newer designs are objectively impossible to melt down, not just from the change in physics, but the safety features which cannot reasonably disabled and the oversight for regular inspections.
Well, everything breaks down after a while. Can’t make an everlasting reactor.
So you can’t completely release it from human error.
Of course, nuclear is definitely better than coal. But it takes so long to build, we’re better off focusing on renewables now. In 30 years we’d have switched almost completely to solar anyway.
Why do you think it takes 30 years? It takes 68 months from bare ground to fully functional.
Yes, but those new designs are more expensive, and since each reactor costs a loooot of money, governments take shortcuts, save money and then accidents happen.
They’re actually not that expensive, overall. The problem is inefficient bureaucracy around it. As a fun fact you can cut the cost in half by repurposing old coal, oil, and natural gas power plants.
They’re insanely expensive up front, it’s just that they’re relatively cheap to run and last a long time so the costs have a low average over time.
Modern nuclear reactors are ~$2k per kWh which is roughly the same as solar.
Again, that’s over their entire, very long lifetime. The costs are high up front for construction and commissioning.
No, we need that money to build out wind and solar now (there’s a climate collapse happening todey), we can’t wait 20+ years for a nuclear reactor to go online.
Fun fact, you still need base load reactors, and fun fact, it takes 5 years to build a nuclear power plant, to be specific, 68 months. From bare ground to fully online and synced with a grid.
But beyond that, solar is nice and can be useful, wind has some uses in some locations, but you have to be okay with being dependent on China since practically zero other countries make solar panels. There are a few, but 80% of all solar panels sold globally are made in China, and if we include local manufacturing, over 99% of all solar panels made are made in China.
I mean I’m okay with that, but EU people specifically get super weirded out by that. Most developed countries have all things necessary for a nuclear power grid and can ensure they can always repair, fuel, and maintain their power plants.
Fun fact, the very concept of base load has been obsolete for a decade. There are times on modern grids where the net power demand goes to zero due to all the solar deployed on rooftops and such. Base load of many grids is zero at this point.
If only we could do multiple things.
So really, the problem is people all the way down
“people are the problem” is foundation of any social and lot of hard sciences 😂
So since we’re people and not angels, maybe we should stick with solar, wind, and batteries. There’s just less of a chance of us colossally breaking something with these.
BWAHAHAHA
Human error is always present. You can’t engineer around it. You can have the best, most safest design possible on paper, but it won’t do any good at all if it isn’t built and maintained the way you designed it.
Now just need to make safety features that cannot be disabled by unreasonable management either.
If anti-nuclear people knew anything about nuclear power, they wouldn’t be anti-nuclear. The Chernobyl powerplant was an RMBK reactor, completely different in structure than other nuclear powerplants. The fossil fuel industry loves misguided opposition against nuclear energy. Read about the RMBK. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RBMK
And the nuclear lobby likes people like you.
Where would Germany get uranium from, by the way?
I hope the nuclear lobby likes me.
Ask them how many people died at Fukushima
One confirmed from radiation (lung cancer, 4 years later), and 2,202 from evacuation.
That’s not what that article says
jdr is right.
The article says “1” and you said “One”.
The text of the article is what I looked at, where they’re a lot less definite.
The 2202 deaths claim is from this article.
If you don’t trust that news site, directly in the article to the left of the info box:
That claim is supported by one government report, two scientific papers and one news site.
And then you have to see what a “disaster-related death” is.
Certainly you didn’t have thousands of people dying at the site, which is what someone might understand if they had taken your numbers at face value.
You support nuclear for psychological reasons, not for technological reasons. It gives you a sense of superiority over your fellow human beings. The real reason nuclear is a dead technology is that it’s simply not cost competitive with renewables and batteries, but you’re here pretending that it’s a bunch of scared superstitious ignorant environmentalists that are dragging it down. THOSE common fools just don’t know the science. THOSE morons just aren’t rational actors like you are. THEY are just to lazy to read about nuclear plant designs.
You’re engaged in a comforting form of self-delusion. The actual barriers to nuclear have nothing to do with people just being irrationally afraid of fission. But you ignore this because it gives you a sense of intellectual superiority.
You support nuclear for psychological rather than technological reasons. Fission is just your sports team.
Different but wrong. I am always interested to know what people’s guesses are for the total number of deaths caused by Chernobyl, because it’s remarkably low in my opinion. It’s by far the safest form of energy generation. Yes, even safer than wind power… why? Simply because wind is a very energy un-dense source of energy so you need to do a lot of construction to obtain it, and construction is a somewhat dangerous job - there’ll be some small number of people who fall off wind turbines (or off rooves while installing solar panels, or whatever) and the huge number of turbines works out as swamping the small number of nuclear plants and tiny number of deadly nuclear disasters.
There were roughly 350,000 innocent human beings who had to abandon their homes due to Chernobyl. The death total was only so low because hundreds of thousands of people had to literally flee for their lives.
Ah guess we should kill more people and build something else then!
Having said that, my numbers are out of date; solar is now safer.
We’ve already accepted the downsides: we’re all held at gunpoint by thousands of nuclear missiles on a daily basis for the past 5 decades and yet there seems to be more people worried about nuclear power than that. We could just as well take advantage of the upside as well.