Disclaimer: We’ve been getting a lot of basic questions about trackers so this is just a primer for people wanting to see what it’s all about. Skip if you are already well versed with trackers, unless you want to read just to contribute or correct me on anything.

What is a private tracker?

Let’s start with what it isn’t. Chances are you are familiar with infamous torrent trackers such as The Pirate Bay and 1337x. These trackers are what’s known as public trackers. “Public” means anyone can visit them and download whatever they want to their heart’s content. This is all fine and dandy, but it does introduce some problems.

  • While you are downloading your file, you are known as a leecher. Once the download is finished, you become a seeder, which means you are done but will continue to upload the data you just downloaded to other downloaders who come along after you. The problem here is that on public trackers, most users stop the torrent, remove it, or close the BitTorrent client as soon as their download is complete. The end result? You have many more leechers than seeders, which equates to slower download speeds and a longer time required to download your files.
  • A peer is another term that can be used to refer to either a seeder or leecher. The swarm is the sum of all peers on a particular torrent. Since anyone can effortlessly access and download files on a public tracker, it leads to unwanted parties gaining access to the swarm and its data, such as copyright holders or their agents. Why is this bad? When you are part of a swarm, you can see the IP addresses of other peers within it. Unless you use a service such as a VPN to mask your identity, your IP address uniquely identifies you on the internet. With this data, parties representing the interests of the people whose content you are pirating can monitor the downloads and issue copyright infringement notices to your ISP, resulting in you receiving nasty letters, having your internet shut off, or possibly facing worse consequences depending on your local laws…
  • Torrents are decentralized, meaning the data isn’t downloaded from a persistent, dedicated location; instead, they rely on the users, particularly the seeders. As mentioned earlier, if you abandon a torrent after finishing, you are no longer a seeder. If enough people do the same, the torrent could end up with zero seeders left, also known as a dead torrent. This means it becomes impossible to complete the download, as the entirety of the data isn’t available in the swarm. Unless a previous seeder decides to return and seed again, nobody will ever be able to download the torrent again. Consequently, a significant amount of niche or older content is lost with the passage of time.
  • So, where do these torrents originally come from? The uploader is the initial seeder of the torrent. On most public trackers, uploading content is almost as easy as downloading it. This large volume of uploads makes moderation difficult. The result? Poor-quality content, fake/mislabeled content, or even viruses.

Private trackers seek to solve these problems by restricting access to the site. Not just anyone can waltz in and download or upload a torrent; you have to be a member. Think of it as the VIP lounge of the pirating world. Here are some of the advantages of this approach:

  • Users are incentivized to keep seeding torrents they’ve downloaded. This means the seeder/leecher ratio is much higher than what would be found on a public site. On a good private tracker, you’ll notice that a majority of the downloads will utilize the full speed of your internet connection and download in the shortest amount of time possible for their size.
  • For the most part, the companies and interested parties mentioned above, who would love to spy and tattle to your ISP about what you download, are completely absent on private trackers. I’ve been using them for over a decade and haven’t encountered a single issue. This means you don’t have to take risks, spend time configuring and updating IP blocklists, or invest money in a VPN.
  • Due to the number of dedicated seeders on private trackers, torrents tend to stay alive much longer, if not indefinitely. This makes private trackers a treasure trove of content. There is a lot that you will only find here. Want to watch some obscure indie film you saw once when you were a kid back in 1989? They’ve got you fam.
  • Due to the controlled nature of private trackers, the content tends to be very well moderated and curated. You can be sure that what you are downloading is exactly what it claims to be, and the quality is excellent as well.
  • Private trackers are more than a download site, they are a community. Many are packed with helpful forums, and members who generally care about the scene and helping one another. Managed to find something that’s actually no on the site already? Many trackers have request systems built in where you can ask the community to find it and upload it for you, and believe it or not, chances are pretty good that someone will!

Ok, but what’s the downside?

Just one really. Your ratio is the amount of data you’ve downloaded on a site compared to how much you’ve uploaded. So, if I’ve downloaded an 8 GB movie but continued to seed it after finishing until I had uploaded 16 GB to other peers, my ratio would be 2.0 (16 ÷ 8). If I downloaded a second 8 GB movie but didn’t upload any data, my ratio would fall to 1.0 ((8 + 8) ÷ 16). Most sites have rules about the ratio you must maintain to encourage people to keep seeding torrents they’ve downloaded. This means, unlike public trackers, you will want to keep seeding after your download has finished so that you can maintain a good ratio and continue to download more content as you please.

So how do I get in?

Private trackers recruit in a variety of ways:

  • Open Signup - The easiest trackers to get into are the ones where you just have to sign up to become a member. Some trackers have what’s known as limited open signup, which means you can’t sign up anytime, but they open signups intermittently when they see fit.
  • Official Recruitment - Some trackers have official representatives who recruit in the forums of other trackers. To qualify, you often have to be a power user on the tracker where the recruitment is taking place. The requirements to achieve this rank vary from tracker to tracker, but typically include uploading a certain amount of data at a minimum.
  • Invites - On many trackers, members who meet certain requirements are given invites to pass out to whomever they want. If you can get someone to give you one of their invites, you’re in.
  • Interviews - There are trackers that conduct official interviews. If you interview and they like you, they’ll let you join.
  • Additionally some trackers will let you buy your way in. I don’t encourage this because for one it’s usually unnecessary, and second because it’s the shadier trackers that usually offer this route anyways.
  • VaultBoyNewVegas@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    My experience with private trackers is that there’s never any open applications and I am not going to spend my time jumping through a dozen hoops to get into a site just so I can download the latest AAA game.

    • Nollij@sopuli.xyz
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 year ago

      Never any open signups? I get that you don’t want to jump through hoops, but TL, Red, MAM, and OPS frequently have open signups/open interviews. No idea if they have the content you want, but I would never download executables from a public tracker unless the source could be verified in a trustworthy way.

      • VaultBoyNewVegas@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        No idea about the specific ones but the ones mentioned on Reddit never have open sign ups whenever I’ve looked. And as I don’t use social media or discord in any way then I’m not going to find out when they do. I don’t need to torrent any movies or shows as I use Kodi and real debris for that and books I use an e reader for and I’ve a library account. So the only thing I would probably torrent would be videogames and I usually get those on sale unless there’s something I want to test on my hardware or I’m not going to buy at all like call of duty and I’d only play the campaign and then delete.

    • pelikan@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      1 year ago

      If you try to get into private trackers to get AAA game you’re definately doing it wrong. There’s ton of trusted public sources like rutracker who will deliver popular stuff with minimum delay (or even without it), checking fmhy links is by far more productive than interview/invite martyrdom. Still there’s a lot of niche stuff which is only present on private trackers but that’s different case.

    • zebs@lemmy.dbzer0.comOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      Not spending time is justifiable, trackers are a time investment for sure. But as far as finding open signups there has been a ton of big trackers with games open recently, I recommend following the telegram channel mentioned in my previous post.

      https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/post/8120741

  • smokin_tent@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 year ago

    Thank you for your explanation, it was quite clarifying for me.

    My question is, how do you come to know about these trackers that have periodic open sign ups?

    • zebs@lemmy.dbzer0.comOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Howdy, I brought that up in my previous post, compiling sources of where to find out about open signups. But basically only two good sources right now besides word of mouth here. Of the two mentioned in the post I currently recommend the telegram channel.

      https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/post/8120741

  • SciPiTie @iusearchlinux.fyi
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Thanks a lot for your writeup! Thanks to you and others I’m now a member of a few private trackers and happily seeding around.

    That said could you please add a few tips how to find open sign-ups or recruitments for the more exclusive trackers? I still try to find some place where I find the doctor who christmas specials after all ;)

    The telegram list you posted seems dead according to another user and the forums and the big R always have the same few it seems - or I’m just too slow / looking in the wrong places :D

    Looking mainly for series and movies, not the most recent stuff necessarily.

    I’m not active in any forums just for the sake of activity for example although I’m a power user on the few trackers I managed to join so far.

    Any tips and pointers would be highly appreciated. Perhaps I’m also just too impatient, my arr sails are up for not even a month :D

  • batman654987@lemmynsfw.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    11 months ago

    Not true at all, first of all you are not leacher until you finish your download thats a lie, you start seeding torent as soon as you download first couple of megabytes and you continey to seed it until you finish downloading and after that also. Second it isnt true that “most people” close torrent right after finishing download because than we would have low download speeds whic is not the case at all, most torrents i download are done in just a couple of minuts. And often there is more seeders than downloaders so im not even uploading anything even thoug im seeding because there is noo need for more seeders. For many torrents yes there should be more seeders but for that to happen people need to understand how torrent works. I think most people doesnt realy get it. Also some people are downloading but do not dare to seed because of laws in their contry so we can forgive them for that i think.