Been thinking about this and want to know if it bugs anyone else.
It’s crazy to me that Twitter, Reddit and Facebook all cut off API access and people just went quiet on it. There was noise and complaints but no solutions. Usually when stuff like this gets locked down a counterculture shows up around it. Workarounds, open alternatives, people who make it their thing to keep it open. Like file sharing or ad blockers.
That didn’t really happen this time and I can’t figure out why. With all the propaganda and fake stuff out there right now, wouldn’t being able to see what’s spreading be important to understand? And isn’t them shutting it down a pretty large signal that it is important?
Maybe there’s a boring explanation I’m missing. But the part that gets me is the other possibility, that there’s some kind of suppression force we might not even be aware of.
Is that terrifying to anyone else or am I overthinking it? Just curious what people who were around for it think.


There are still ways to scrape reddit content without the API, the data isn’t ‘closed’ despite their anticonsumer practices. The main thing you need API for is participating in those sites, and if you want to know what the fighting back is… Well, you’re looking at it. We left! I’m having a grand old time.
I agree. I also wonder why anyone would want to fight for a site that keeps getting worse and worse?
And not by accident!
Because these spaces now generate so much racism and anti science and anti leftist trash that it leaks into every part of culture and society. I watch kids on their phones all day. They don’t go to lemmy. They go to Facebook, TikTok, Twitter, Reddit. Everybody here is saying left leaning users all left so what is left? What content are the kids today seeing and learning and building their world views from? I get you don’t personally like it. But are you ready for these kids to be voting and running for government and being your coworkers and employer in the next 10 years?
I agree with the sentiment but there honestly isn’t much to be done about it. There actually was a lot of outrage and counter culture; I was there for it. The problem is that all that outrage was hosted on the very platform being criticised.
It was was easily silenced en-masse by moderators and admins. Posts went up detailing the horrifying extent of the censorship, but those were quickly shut down as well. You won’t find any evidence of this; it’s effectively been erased from history. Nowadays it would be shut down even harder with their A.I. automods.
The only actionable outcome was people quietly left. Not everyone, only the ones who cared enough. Which was less than hoped for. Most people using Reddit, Facebook, TikTok, Instagram, Twitter, etc nowadays don’t really know or care. They don’t realise what they’ve lost or how it used to be different.
I think that’s just the fate of all “mainstream media”. Reddit isn’t a thread based forum anymore. It’s a media / mass communication website. We’re not welcome there anymore.
Right OK thank you. So this was my experience and I thought I was going crazy. There is this erasure of these events that is making me go crazy. I know we all know these things happened but like the voices of the time seem to move on.
I just thought it when this happened with games and software, people emerged like fitgirl and others who were capable of reverse engineering these insane cryptographic graphic systems to make sure we all could get season 5 of big bang theory. Without them, people would also say “we can’t do anything” so I think the problem isn’t that its some impossible task but that maybe we’re shitting the bed somehow.
What really scares me is that given what we know about online culture. With how fast things move. With how controlled many spaces are. Maybe the fact we’re moving on and forgetting these battles is by design. Because things feel different. The left feels different.
Yeah there’s a lot of gaslighting inherit to online spaces. Once it’s deleted there’s no proof it ever existed.
All of us are learning that the social contract we had with cooperations were only as strong as the paper they were printed on; the joke being they were never even printed. Terms of conditions and privacy policy can be updated at any time - i.e. we’re the ones in control, not you, and we don’t care how you feel about it
I think it really marks a split in the web. “Curated online ecosystems” like Reddit, Twitter, YouTube, etc vs “underground spaces” like Lemmy and independent websites. I’d wager a majority of organic web traffic is trapped within those app ecosystems. People aren’t even aware they’re being manipulated, because they don’t see anything they’re not supposed to see, according to the algorithm
Ok so you’re last paragraph. How do you know lemmy isn’t the curated space. Isn’t it weird we all did this exodus to a much smaller space like we’re shoved into a corner. It isn’t like this place is generating much. It isn’t like 4chan of the left where we’re generating any culture. There’s no mematic culture. It feels like a snuff box to me. It’s over moderated. Everything has a box and none of this boxes are conducive to creativity, or conflict or anything human that generates feelings outside of just reading a post and then agreeing with everybody there. Because there’s no conflict or pressure due to over moderation lemmy is just a genetic vanilla site. It’s the missionary position
The difference here is federation. I could go make my own instance right now with my own rules. I notice you’re on lemmy.world, which has defederated (blocked, essentially) many instances the admins deemed problematic. It has also been blocked by many other instances. We’re kind of insular here like that, you can never see “all” of Lemmy.
For example lemmy.ml is known to have a lot of nutjobs. Interestingly, they were the ones who “started” Lemmy, so it’s funny to see them getting shunned by everyone else now it’s gotten bigger. You can see the list here (under blocked instances section): https://lemmy.world/instances
Further reading: https://lemmy.world/post/1246945
Note that sh.itjust.works has much more defederation since that post. Most instances should have a similar list.
Just from speaking briefly I actually think .world is not the instance for you. There are other instances with much broader federation, where you can decide what to see or not on your own. A lot of right wing stuff is blocked by .world for example.
hexbear.net is an infamous example… Which actually blocks .world and vice versa! If you go browse hexbear all (top day), it’s a VERY different experience.
Sorry I don’t have an actual recommendation for you but I don’t know of any instances which are federated with all other instances and no other instances have defederated with them… It’s bi-directional that way so either side can block the other. But world is probably one of the worst in regards to walled gardens since it’s the biggest it kind of just does it’s own thing.
I think they voted this last time, and I’m all in. There are all ages here on lemmy