Why? It’s what cull means. I can’t think of a better use. Killing livestock because they are ill, to prevent the disease from spreading, is the best example I can think of for the word “cull”.
Who defines the meaning of words if not the people reading or speaking them?
I acknowledge that cull has a specific meaning in animal industry, but it also happens to be a useful to distance the more visceral implications of what’s actually occurring in the real world.
Similarly saying a soldier “eliminated” an enemy soldier (or “combatant”) is perfectly accurate but also linguistically very convenient if you’re trying to keep people from thinking about the dead man and his grieving family.
“Cull” in this case also makes it sound routine or normal, when it’s actually the result of negligence. Chickens should not be packed in like that so tight that they’re in proximity to almost 2 million others.
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culling just putting this up here so we’re looking at the same thing. And I never said slaughter, so I’m not sure why you bring it up.)
But anyway your comment is correct in that words have meaning. To me cull sounds routine and normal as in that’s just what you do with a spoiled batch, or if you want to do some selective breeding, etc etc (weird, but whatever).
I believe using the special bloodless euphemisms of the field* makes things seem more distant than everyday words that have the same meaning but more viscerality.
Maybe cull to you communicates all this in which case congratulations on being so woke, but to me and many other people, the word carries much less oomph.
*eg. cull, eliminate, liquidate, render, etc, depending on the field
EDIT oh I see someone a few comments up used the word slaughter. Yeah, clearly not the best choice of words but my point is about cull.
You called me out because I pointed out that people use one word to hide the savagery of what is happening by destroying living animals due to gross mismanagement that put them into the position in the first place. Your problem is with me having a different viewpoint than you, and so you lash out over it. This is a question of intolerance on your part and an unwillingness to accept that people can see the world differently. Then you add in the entitlement to push your world view onto other people and make it personal.
and trying to get rid of their comfortable ignorance that fills them full of undeserved and self centered righteous indignation is the most egregious of personal attacks.
And the miserable part is, is if chickens were raised like people like them wanted… Then chicken would cost 30+ dollars a pound. because you would lose the benefit of scale.
God forbid the life of a chicken is worth more than an hour of minimum wage work. Y’all would be frothing at the mouths if a kitten slaughterhouse opened in your city.
As far as I know the most ethically raised chickens, that are least not raised in dirty stacked cages crapping on each other, do not cost anywhere close to $30 a pound. Sure, they may still have extremely limited area to be in, but are fed better feed. In my opinion, this is still a better life than the worst factory conditions. Also, scale would also help drive down the cost of better treated chickens. Additionally, there is also a cost to cosumers’ health; cosuming chickens filled with cheap feed, and sometimes high antibiotic levels.
“Slaughter” means killed for meat (and/or other products).
“Cull” means killed but not otherwise used.
Cull is worse than slaughter because the lives are just wasted without any benefit other than hopefully containing the spread of disease. They were all going to be slaughtered in the normal case. I think that’s pretty well understood.
But culled doesn’t have the same effect as murdered or butchered or slaughtered. Culled has the same connotation as being “put to sleep” but in reality they are typically violently gassed or suffocated and left until they die.
That’s a massacre and if it were performed on humans, we’d call it something much worse.
Not arguing that that effect isn’t real, but it’s one I just don’t get.
To me, “cull” implies death just as much as “slaughtered”. “Butchered” isn’t even about the act of killing but the act of cutting the meat into the desired cuts (I get that it’s used in place of “killed” to imply some brutality but when talking about livestock it can make it less clear if the meat was then used or just destroyed).
It can also just make it seem sensationalised when trying to use words that invoke a stronger emotional reaction. It only resonates with those who already agree. Like the “meat is murder” slogan will get nods from those who agree but rolled eyes from those that don’t. I just don’t think that changing the word used to describe the thing is going to make much of a difference for those that understand the meaning of the word. Just like using words like “culled” doesn’t actually downplay anything for you.
For those that don’t understand, ok, I could see that affecting how people feel about something. Or adding those specifics about the method used and the unnecessary cruelty involved. Or specifics about the conditions that lead to scenarios where over a million birds end up getting culled. Your second sentence is a lot more convincing to me than just using the words from your first sentence.
After re-reading the post, it’s honestly the genuine reality that is missing from articles like this. Its narrative is framed in a way that only narrows its scope to animals as commodities to be produced and consumed. It’s an abstraction that removes the messiness of what we do to fuel our current way of life.
I shouldn’t expect much more from an Aljazeera economy section article but it’s honestly a good example of how this abstraction can separate our perspectives. Of course it’s going to mean something different for a market analysist, a livestock farmer, a meat eater, or a vegan but if that’s the case then why make it ambiguous? Why try to hide the truth from people?
There’s no mention of how these animals will be culled, what will be done with the remains, or how we could do better in the future. But that’s the point that is being swept under the rug, it’s not about any of those things; it’s about how you should expect egg prices to go up and not be upset. It’s an article meant to relieve the burden of the reality of our actions as a society.
I think that’s the point I’m trying to make when the word cull doesn’t cut it.
Why? It’s what cull means. I can’t think of a better use. Killing livestock because they are ill, to prevent the disease from spreading, is the best example I can think of for the word “cull”.
Because nobody wants to use the word “slaughter” since it has moral implications and everyone wants to eat dead animals without guilt.
No, words have meaning.
Hate to be the one that breaks that to you.
Cull is fine, your own lack of knowledge isn’t.
Who defines the meaning of words if not the people reading or speaking them?
I acknowledge that cull has a specific meaning in animal industry, but it also happens to be a useful to distance the more visceral implications of what’s actually occurring in the real world.
Similarly saying a soldier “eliminated” an enemy soldier (or “combatant”) is perfectly accurate but also linguistically very convenient if you’re trying to keep people from thinking about the dead man and his grieving family.
“Cull” in this case also makes it sound routine or normal, when it’s actually the result of negligence. Chickens should not be packed in like that so tight that they’re in proximity to almost 2 million others.
Because slaughter in reference to animals implies butchering to market 🤦♂️
Culling is done for other reasons and are not brought to market.
Words have meaning!
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culling just putting this up here so we’re looking at the same thing. And I never said slaughter, so I’m not sure why you bring it up.)
But anyway your comment is correct in that words have meaning. To me cull sounds routine and normal as in that’s just what you do with a spoiled batch, or if you want to do some selective breeding, etc etc (weird, but whatever).
I believe using the special bloodless euphemisms of the field* makes things seem more distant than everyday words that have the same meaning but more viscerality.
Maybe cull to you communicates all this in which case congratulations on being so woke, but to me and many other people, the word carries much less oomph.
*eg. cull, eliminate, liquidate, render, etc, depending on the field
EDIT oh I see someone a few comments up used the word slaughter. Yeah, clearly not the best choice of words but my point is about cull.
It’s most notable that you made a neutral conversation into a personal attack. It was unnecessary.
Lacking in knowledge is not a personal attack, everyone lacks knowledge.
Coming on to a platform and espousing such misinformation opens you up to criticism.
Hope this helps!
This is a personal attack. Take off your savior cape, nobody asked you for help. Stop being toxic, it’s much easier to live that way.
You need to go back to tumblr if you are this incapable of the most neutral and calm of human interaction.
It’s not a personal attack lol.
Spreading misinformation is wrong, I called you out, you are now burrowing because you were wrong, looking weaker by the post.
You called me out because I pointed out that people use one word to hide the savagery of what is happening by destroying living animals due to gross mismanagement that put them into the position in the first place. Your problem is with me having a different viewpoint than you, and so you lash out over it. This is a question of intolerance on your part and an unwillingness to accept that people can see the world differently. Then you add in the entitlement to push your world view onto other people and make it personal.
Cull is the correct word to use.
From Merriam Webster
How about from Cambridge?
You can be grumpy but like already said lack of knowledge is not grounds for your behavior
Dude.
Words have meaning, that’s literally it.
What part of this is not computing?
But you tried to educate him.
and trying to get rid of their comfortable ignorance that fills them full of undeserved and self centered righteous indignation is the most egregious of personal attacks.
The dumbest part is I don’t agree with insane factory farming either.
I just think it’s important to have the right discussions.
More ethical farmers and farming also uses culling.
Dude just doesn’t want to learn
And the miserable part is, is if chickens were raised like people like them wanted… Then chicken would cost 30+ dollars a pound. because you would lose the benefit of scale.
God forbid the life of a chicken is worth more than an hour of minimum wage work. Y’all would be frothing at the mouths if a kitten slaughterhouse opened in your city.
As far as I know the most ethically raised chickens, that are least not raised in dirty stacked cages crapping on each other, do not cost anywhere close to $30 a pound. Sure, they may still have extremely limited area to be in, but are fed better feed. In my opinion, this is still a better life than the worst factory conditions. Also, scale would also help drive down the cost of better treated chickens. Additionally, there is also a cost to cosumers’ health; cosuming chickens filled with cheap feed, and sometimes high antibiotic levels.
There’s a ton of ugly truth all over that people do not want to deal with.
There are places literally called slaughterhouses. If you work or live on or around a farm you’d probably hear the word slaughter at least monthly
“Slaughter” means killed for meat (and/or other products).
“Cull” means killed but not otherwise used.
Cull is worse than slaughter because the lives are just wasted without any benefit other than hopefully containing the spread of disease. They were all going to be slaughtered in the normal case. I think that’s pretty well understood.
But culled doesn’t have the same effect as murdered or butchered or slaughtered. Culled has the same connotation as being “put to sleep” but in reality they are typically violently gassed or suffocated and left until they die.
That’s a massacre and if it were performed on humans, we’d call it something much worse.
Not arguing that that effect isn’t real, but it’s one I just don’t get.
To me, “cull” implies death just as much as “slaughtered”. “Butchered” isn’t even about the act of killing but the act of cutting the meat into the desired cuts (I get that it’s used in place of “killed” to imply some brutality but when talking about livestock it can make it less clear if the meat was then used or just destroyed).
It can also just make it seem sensationalised when trying to use words that invoke a stronger emotional reaction. It only resonates with those who already agree. Like the “meat is murder” slogan will get nods from those who agree but rolled eyes from those that don’t. I just don’t think that changing the word used to describe the thing is going to make much of a difference for those that understand the meaning of the word. Just like using words like “culled” doesn’t actually downplay anything for you.
For those that don’t understand, ok, I could see that affecting how people feel about something. Or adding those specifics about the method used and the unnecessary cruelty involved. Or specifics about the conditions that lead to scenarios where over a million birds end up getting culled. Your second sentence is a lot more convincing to me than just using the words from your first sentence.
After re-reading the post, it’s honestly the genuine reality that is missing from articles like this. Its narrative is framed in a way that only narrows its scope to animals as commodities to be produced and consumed. It’s an abstraction that removes the messiness of what we do to fuel our current way of life.
I shouldn’t expect much more from an Aljazeera economy section article but it’s honestly a good example of how this abstraction can separate our perspectives. Of course it’s going to mean something different for a market analysist, a livestock farmer, a meat eater, or a vegan but if that’s the case then why make it ambiguous? Why try to hide the truth from people?
There’s no mention of how these animals will be culled, what will be done with the remains, or how we could do better in the future. But that’s the point that is being swept under the rug, it’s not about any of those things; it’s about how you should expect egg prices to go up and not be upset. It’s an article meant to relieve the burden of the reality of our actions as a society.
I think that’s the point I’m trying to make when the word cull doesn’t cut it.