• merc@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    10 days ago

    What’s amazing is that Americans don’t live in a purely capitalist state. Nobody does. Every major country in the world has a mix of capitalism and socialism. AFAIK no country has purely private firefighters. UPS and FedEx exist, but so does the national postal service. In many countries various utilities like water, sewer, electrical, etc are publicly owned, but in most places the phone service is private.

    China initially went full publicly owned, but it was a disaster, so they now have a mix of public and private. Cuba has had to open up its economy to allow privately owned businesses. Meanwhile, the US learned long ago that purely private is a disaster. Policing used to be private, run by companies like the Pinkertons. Firefighting used to be for-profit only.

    90% of people campaigning for “socialism” are talking about European-style socalism, at least as a first step. A social safety net. Healthcare provided by the state. Utilities owned by the state, or at least heavily regulated, etc.

    But, Americans, while they love the fire department and couldn’t imagine replacing it with a for-profit fire service, somehow think the economy will collapse if the government opens a grocery store.

    • mechoman444@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      10 days ago

      Yeah… Most of the comments section looks something like this.

      Nothing you have mentioned is socialism. Private healthcare, publicly funded firefighters, state-owned utilities, or your examples of China introducing free-market principles into its one-party system. None of these things, individually or collectively, constitute socialism. What you are describing, as usual, is social democracy, which uses the word social to describe a capitalist economy with an extensive welfare state.

      Providing social welfare programs is a fundamental function of virtually every form of government. Whether it is communism, democracy, or dictatorship, governments have historically implemented programs intended to provide some level of social welfare to their populations. That does not make these systems a mixture of socialism and capitalism. It makes them different political and economic systems providing social services through different mechanisms. In China’s case, for example, you have a political system rooted in one-party communist rule incorporating significant elements of capitalism. An interesting hybrid, certainly, but that does not mean its economy is socialist in the traditional economic sense.

      Your argument that every economy in the world is a hybrid, followed by the assertion that these hybrid economies specifically incorporate socialism, is fundamentally incorrect. I will agree that most modern economies have some degree of hybridization, but they ultimately retain their underlying economic identity.

      Take the Nordic countries, for example. Denmark, Norway, and Sweden are deeply capitalist countries with incredibly strong free markets. The distinction is that their governments play a significantly larger role in regulating markets and providing social welfare services than the United States does.

      By the way, the same principle applies to China. Its private sector and free-market activities are heavily regulated to accommodate the interests of the ruling Communist Party. When private enterprise grows beyond what the government considers acceptable, the state has demonstrated that it is more than willing to intervene aggressively.

      What you are describing and advocating for is social democracy. Not democratic socialism, but very specifically social democracy.

      It is genuinely astonishing how consistently people advocate for an economic and political philosophy without understanding the fundamental distinctions between the systems they are attempting to support.

      • merc@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        10 days ago

        Nothing you have mentioned is socialism

        Of course it’s socialism. It’s genuinely astonishing how people don’t understand that virtually every country in the world right now has a Mixed Economy: “A mixed economy is an economic system that includes both elements associated with capitalism, such as private businesses, and ones associated with socialism, such as nationalized government services.”

        Providing social welfare programs is a fundamental function of virtually every form of government

        And the mechanism through which that is done is… socialism. The government could choose not to do any of those things and let the free market sort it out and it would be… capitalism. This isn’t rocket surgery.

        Your argument that every economy in the world is a hybrid

        The correct term is Mixed Economy.

        specifically incorporate socialism, is fundamentally incorrect

        No, it is a standard view, as you can see if you just read that Wikipedia entry.

        • mechoman444@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          10 days ago

          Clearly, you didn’t read anything I said, glossed over it, or simply failed to comprehend my argument.

          I apologize that you didn’t like my use of the word hybrid. It is also a perfectly acceptable term when discussing what you call mixed economies. But I guess you didn’t read the Wikipedia article either.

          I expressly stated that I fully agree that most economies are, to use your terminology, mixed, while still retaining their fundamental economic identity.

          Social programs are not inherently socialist. Any form of government, operating under any economic system, can have social welfare programs. They are not exclusive to socialism. Socialism is an economic system, and calling social welfare programs socialism is simply incorrect. You could argue that some of these programs have similarities to policies historically associated with communist governments, but what they actually are is social welfare. They have nothing inherently to do with socialism.

          That is an objective distinction, regardless of what Wikipedia has to say about it.

          The people on this platform do not support or propagate socialism because they don’t understand what socialism actually is. What they support and advocate for is social democracy. Specifically, they don’t even advocate for democratic socialism because, once again, they don’t understand the distinction.

          And then you show up saying, “No, no, it is socialism,” when objectively, it isn’t.

          Saying that an economy with a GDP as large as that of the United States is a mixed economy, using your terminology, is a gross oversimplification of what the American economy actually is. Of course, it has some elements of public ownership alongside significantly larger elements of private ownership. Nobody is arguing otherwise. But overwhelmingly, and by a considerable margin, it is a capitalist economy.

          Trying to make an argument for socialism within a capitalist economy simply because it has some mixed characteristics is not a particularly compelling argument.

          If you compare the American capitalist economy to any country that is currently socialist or was historically socialist, you will see two fundamentally different kinds of economies operating on entirely different premises and at entirely different scales.

          Saying that the American economy is capitalist with socialist elements makes very little sense. At best, it indicates that certain industries or services operate under public ownership, which is perfectly normal and does not, by itself, make an economy socialist.

          So, thank you for pointing me toward the Wikipedia article. It was genuinely helpful. I hope you’re satisfied that I used the term mixed economy instead of hybrid.