What do you mean? Do you think the CPC doesn’t have 100,000,000 members, or do you think the CPC isn’t Marxist-Leninist? What leads you to believe either?
How are they not ML? China isn’t capitalist, social ownership is the principal (rising and dominant) aspect of the economy, and the working class controls the state. According to classical Marxist economics, the material base of planned economy is in large, centralized industry, while the material base of markets are in decentralized and underdeveloped industry.
The PRC therefore marketizes underdeveloped industry as it naturally develops into centralized production, at which point they can effectively plan it. To maintain markets at high centralization is to enshittify, to plan underdeveloped industry is to place immense strain on administration due to the lack of developed infrastructure.
What do you think a Marxist-Leninist party would do? Dogmatically collectivize the economy, even against Marxist economics? Socialist countries in siege sometimes do that, because of the need for security, but if you can avoid that path it’s better to avoid increasing productive contradictions.
Well, for one thing they’re not constantly being dickhead assholes to everyone. They know they have to work with people, so they compromise where they can and aren’t incessantly punching down on those they perceive as “beneath” them.
But in all seriousness, if they’ve got billionaires in their society (which they do), and they’ve got homeless people (which they do), then they’re just as bad as any capitalist country. Add in their persecution of LGBTQ and other social “deviants” (in their minds), and their extreme censorship, and they’re just as bad as any conservative country.
I don’t even know what you and I are arguing about anymore. All I know is that the MLs online are fucking dicks, and they have ZERO interest in bringing ANYONE to their side of thinking economically. All they care about is shitting on “libs”.
Your personal experiences with MLs aside, the CPC is definitely ML. The fact that they have billionaires is a consequence of having private property, and Marxists don’t believe private property to be a moral sin but instead something that is progressive at some levels of development and reactionary at higher levels. China does have some few homeless people, but the number shrinks every year. It’s enormously different from capitalist countries in terms of how rapidly they are improving for working people.
Sorry that your personal experience has been sour. However, I’d encourage you to put yourself in the shoes of an ML, surrounded by people far to your right. Many end up jaded and short-tempered, it takes a certain level of stubbornness to try to be patient.
And you are documenting them while they do it? I’d like to share an analogy with you:
I cant stand 2 things:
The Kardashians
People who spend their entire lives loudly telling everyone they hate the Kardashians.
I hope the analogy is clear without leaving me open to being called a tankie by some politically illiterate neckbeard. Not specifically knocking you Guy Dudeman, I’m just making a point about the tankies and the tankie haters as they appear from the outside. It is rampant, and extremely fucking tiring.
Cheers, and thanks for understanding - I had just gotten out of a conversation where no less than three separate users were adamant that donald trump is a tankie, and russia is the soviet union, right now. No joke, you can look at my history. It’s fuckin pathological. Anyway, have a good one <3
You can use whatever scary term you want for the phantoms who you hold responsible for all the problems in your life.
MLs literally don’t affect my life at all. That’s the problem. They don’t do anything except hang out online and make fun of the libs.
China doesn’t impact you? They’re run by an ML party of 100,000,000 people.
No they’re not.
What do you mean? Do you think the CPC doesn’t have 100,000,000 members, or do you think the CPC isn’t Marxist-Leninist? What leads you to believe either?
They’re not ML. They say they are. But they’re not. They’re just as capitalist as any other country. It just has “Chinese characteristics”. LOL
How are they not ML? China isn’t capitalist, social ownership is the principal (rising and dominant) aspect of the economy, and the working class controls the state. According to classical Marxist economics, the material base of planned economy is in large, centralized industry, while the material base of markets are in decentralized and underdeveloped industry.
The PRC therefore marketizes underdeveloped industry as it naturally develops into centralized production, at which point they can effectively plan it. To maintain markets at high centralization is to enshittify, to plan underdeveloped industry is to place immense strain on administration due to the lack of developed infrastructure.
What do you think a Marxist-Leninist party would do? Dogmatically collectivize the economy, even against Marxist economics? Socialist countries in siege sometimes do that, because of the need for security, but if you can avoid that path it’s better to avoid increasing productive contradictions.
Well, for one thing they’re not constantly being dickhead assholes to everyone. They know they have to work with people, so they compromise where they can and aren’t incessantly punching down on those they perceive as “beneath” them.
But in all seriousness, if they’ve got billionaires in their society (which they do), and they’ve got homeless people (which they do), then they’re just as bad as any capitalist country. Add in their persecution of LGBTQ and other social “deviants” (in their minds), and their extreme censorship, and they’re just as bad as any conservative country.
I don’t even know what you and I are arguing about anymore. All I know is that the MLs online are fucking dicks, and they have ZERO interest in bringing ANYONE to their side of thinking economically. All they care about is shitting on “libs”.
Your personal experiences with MLs aside, the CPC is definitely ML. The fact that they have billionaires is a consequence of having private property, and Marxists don’t believe private property to be a moral sin but instead something that is progressive at some levels of development and reactionary at higher levels. China does have some few homeless people, but the number shrinks every year. It’s enormously different from capitalist countries in terms of how rapidly they are improving for working people.
Sorry that your personal experience has been sour. However, I’d encourage you to put yourself in the shoes of an ML, surrounded by people far to your right. Many end up jaded and short-tempered, it takes a certain level of stubbornness to try to be patient.
And you are documenting them while they do it? I’d like to share an analogy with you:
I cant stand 2 things:
I hope the analogy is clear without leaving me open to being called a tankie by some politically illiterate neckbeard. Not specifically knocking you Guy Dudeman, I’m just making a point about the tankies and the tankie haters as they appear from the outside. It is rampant, and extremely fucking tiring.
Believe me… I’m with you. I wish everyone could just get along and cooperate.
Cheers, and thanks for understanding - I had just gotten out of a conversation where no less than three separate users were adamant that donald trump is a tankie, and russia is the soviet union, right now. No joke, you can look at my history. It’s fuckin pathological. Anyway, have a good one <3
LOL! That is insane.