Anarchist: Great, let’s burn down parliament tonight and do communism tomorrow!
ML: That’s stupid, we can’t have communism now! We need to coup parliament and then have 100 years of socialism with slow moderate reforms towards communism.
Anarchist: I think we can just do communism now, though.
ML: Well look who’s a liberal wrecker, trying to destroy our movement. Did the CIA send you?
Most of the ML arguments about why immediate communism wouldn’t work revolve around the fact that in every historical revolution that burned down Parliament, the capitalists, with all of their wealth and power, still existed and fought with everything they had to rebuild Parliament. Not to mention that most of the people were still heavily influenced by capitalist ideology and superstructures. Doesn’t seem realistic to expect communism to survive without a centralized army to defend it and a coherent society and economy to supply it, and it doesn’t seem realistic for a society that immediately tries for communism to be coherent.
Anarchist: I want to have a communist revolution
ML: Me too!
Anarchist: Great, let’s burn down parliament tonight and do communism tomorrow!
ML: That’s stupid, we can’t have communism now! We need to coup parliament and then have 100 years of socialism with slow moderate reforms towards communism.
Anarchist: I think we can just do communism now, though.
ML: Well look who’s a liberal wrecker, trying to destroy our movement. Did the CIA send you?
Most of the ML arguments about why immediate communism wouldn’t work revolve around the fact that in every historical revolution that burned down Parliament, the capitalists, with all of their wealth and power, still existed and fought with everything they had to rebuild Parliament. Not to mention that most of the people were still heavily influenced by capitalist ideology and superstructures. Doesn’t seem realistic to expect communism to survive without a centralized army to defend it and a coherent society and economy to supply it, and it doesn’t seem realistic for a society that immediately tries for communism to be coherent.